None of us question the miracle of light when we flip a light switch, but biases that surround the electric car have been difficult to dislodge. Part of this was the industry’s own fault. Detroit has been reluctant to re-tool and dragged its feet when it came to investing in the technology. Another part of the fault squarely belongs to the public. We have been unwilling to support an electric vehicle unless it gave us exactly the same performance a gasoline-powered vehicle could.
In other words, we have all been pretty short-sighted in the past, so let’s look at the myths surrounding this technology and see what the science is.
Myth: Electric cars can only go 20 or 30 miles before their battery runs out.
False: Tesla’s all electric vehicles have ranges of 160, 230 and 300 miles, depending on the model.
People tend to confuse the technology of electric vehicles with hybrids. Chevrolet’s new Volt scheduled for release in 2010/2011 will allow 40 miles in its fully electric battery mode but has a backup capacity of 300 additional miles with a gasoline-powered electric generator. It is a competitor to a full EV, but it isn’t fully electric even if its general operation is.
Myth: Electric cars are unreliable in inclement weather.
False: If you were one of the lucky ones at the Carlton Hotel in Switzerland the weekend of February 13th and 14th, 2010, you would back me up here. Tesla offered free test drives in the exclusive St. Moritz neighborhood and wowed the crowd. To date 1000 roadsters have been delivered to 21 countries, including 30 in Switzerland, and they are oh-so-pretty.
The company’s press release touted the car’s ”all-weather durability and its solid performance in the rugged Alps”. This may not seem like a hoard of vehicles coming to a neighborhood near you, but every major manufacturer recognizes this is the future and each is trying to bring an electric vehicle (EV) to market. To keep it simple, the examples I use here are Tesla models, but there are many other manufacturers.
Myth: Slow acceleration makes electric cars a problem in traffic, on freeways and can hinder maneuverability in driving.
False: First of all, let’s stop thinking 20th Century here. The Roadster has no tailpipe emissions, is twice as energy efficient as a hybrid and it accelerates faster than a Porsche. EVs vary depending on their cost, but we are way past the old go-cart days.
Myth: Electric vehicles need more maintenance than gasoline-powered engines.
False: How can a vehicle that has no spark plugs, no fuel tank, no fuel pump, no tail pipe, etc., require more maintenance? You will want to check the batteries once a month, add water when needed and keep the connections tight and clean. Inflate your tires properly, maintain the brakes, clutch and suspension and that’s about it. Depending on whether you buy a conversion or a new model, at about 80,000 miles you should change the brushes on the motor.
Myth: Electric Vehicles (EV) need special electrical outlets.
True: Although it consumes no gasoline, a Tesla roadster does require a plug to recharge. The only thing special about the voltage, however, is where you want to plug it in. Europe’s electrical voltage is different from ours, so their electric cars will plug into a 220volt/50hertz electrical outlet. The U.S. electric grid – based on what we consider a safer system - has 110 volt/60hertz electricity. Tesla provides a search site for charging stations in the United States which are 120volt and 208-240volt. It might be noted here that the car can be fully or partially recharged with solar or wind power, which are completely renewable.
If your garage is wired, you will already have a 120volt plug and an 8-hour charge should do it. At a commercial charging station at 240volt electricity, 3 hours would be sufficient for a full charge. However, more than one word of caution for do-it-yourselfers about putting in a 240volt plug in your own garage. This kind of voltage can be deadly and building codes require the plug be grounded. (I use a 240volt plug for a kiln and as a safety precaution turn off the electricity whenever I am handling the plug. It is probably overkill but it rains a lot where I live and water conducts electricity.)
Myth: Electric cars are delicate and should not be taken to places where they might under perform, like really high altitudes.
False: As the electric vehicles use no oxygen (imagine!), high or low altitude makes no difference in their operation. On the other hand, any of you who have driven or lived on a higher plain know that downshifting is your only choice with a fossil-fuel vehicle. Passing a truck on Alpine roads in a gas-guzzler of any kind – which does use oxygen – is probably a death wish. Okay, so it could be a death wish in an EV as well, but you get my point.
Myth: These vehicles are way too expensive for the average family.
Half-truth: This depends on your definition of average. The Tesla Roadster retails around 84,000 Euros (US$114,046) overseas before taxes but it is about $101,500 base price in the U.S. - if you can get on the waiting list. The Telsa Model S, a sedan that seats seven, will retail for about $49,900. Its higher performance Model S Signature has not been priced yet, but it is limited to 1000 vehicles, so it will probably have a 25% to 50% premium on top of that.
Myth: All EVs use some sort of backup fossil fuel.
False: Tesla’s promotional literature appeals to the net-zero crowd with this kind of copy:
“If you really want zero emissions, electric vehicles can be powered from 100 percent renewable energy. You even can generate your own energy to fuel them by installing solar panels that last for decades. Good luck trying to drill an oil well in your back yard!”
Granted it’s a bit snarky, but effective. 100% renewable and under your own control – not OPEC’s or Venezuela’s or Shell’s – has a a lot of appeal. Other manufacturers attempting to make these EVs and hybrids more affordable are using many different combinations of technologies. Eventually one will come out on top and then, as greater volume production is realized, the prices will drop. Really. In the early 1980’s a 20 MB personal computer was about $3500. There was no family vacation that year, but we bought one for our business and we were never sorry. Now these new EV prototypes are appealing, if expensive, in the same way. Electric vehicles are poised to dominate the market as the cost of non-renewables will escalate.
Purchase price and environmental benefits aside, the other consideration is the electricity cost to run an EV. The U.S. government will begin to aggressively tax non-renewables to discourage their use – which is already done all over Europe. The electricity that costs a quarter of what gasoline would to fuel the same mileage today may be only a tenth of the cost in a decade. Taking an average daily commute in a gasoline powered car at $5 a day, a commuter would save $900 annually with an EV. Anyone with an EV will need to pay to charge it somewhere, so setting up charging stations within your apartment complex could be a significant profit center. The earnings could also be used to justify setting up a solar photovoltaic system, which should last a long time with even decent maintenance and thrill your greener tenants even if they are paying for it.
The question is, will we get ahead of the curve or follow behind? If you manage a property for yourself or an employer, being grid ready will be important to you. When you do add electrical charging outlets for your residents – which you eventually will have to do – you may want to set up a net-metering system. This should not fall under rent control but if there is no regulation in your area – or interpretation is murky - writing up a green lease that covers this may be something to incorporate in your practices now.
Myth: You can build your own solar charging station at home .
True: Maybe you can, but I know I would definitely have to hire a professional. Tesla’s CEO is also the Chairman at SolarCity, which makes one utter… how convenient… but to this I have neither argument nor criticism. SolarCity has been a pioneer in leasing and financing home solar photovoltaic systems in the western states and Arizona. As the cost of these systems has been a barrier to quicker adoption, I would like to see them and their competitors go national as quickly as they can.
Synergy is a key concept in sustainability. If we would actually stop competing so heavily and share some technology for the good of the planet, we might get to a net-zero result faster. I like partnerships like Tesla and SolarCity, particularly if the two companies collaborate to produce inexpensive, long-term financing and eliminate the ’advance cost’ barrier. If Americans try photovoltaics on their garage to charge their EVs, they may like them enough to consider converting their homes. Yes, the sun does not always shine and the wind does not always blow, but that’s why God made batteries.
Myth: The $7500 Federal Tax Credit applies to electric vehicles like the Tesla Roadster.
True: Because state and federal policy change frequently, Tesla has an EV Incentive link you can search on your own. Until at least December 31, 2010, the Roadster and their other models currently qualify for the full $7500 federal tax credit. There may also be local utility companies and municiple governments that will kick in a rebate or incentive. Many employers will pay for parking for EVs and some cities allow free parking passes or at least special parking privileges, so do your research. There may be other incentives you can get for setting up a solar-charging station as a business or a residence. Check with the Department of Energy (DOE) for updates, but the current policy for the EV tax credit in government-speak is:
“The minimum amount of the credit for qualified plug-in electric drive vehicles is $2,500 and the credit tops out at $7,500, depending on the battery capacity. To qualify, vehicles must be newly purchased, have four or more wheels, have a gross vehicle weight rating of less than 14,000 lbs, and draw propulsion using a battery with at least four kilowatt hours that can be recharged from an external source of electricity. The full amount of the credit will be reduced with respect to a manufacturer’s vehicles after the manufacturer has sold at least 200,000 vehicles. The credit will then phase out over a year. ”
Myth: Electric cars are ugly.
Totally false: These cars are not only quiet and fumeless, but when you gaze upon that Roadster or that Sport… admit it. All you can think is nice ride.
Photos courtesy of the North American International Auto Show (NAIAS).
If you enjoyed this article, you may be interested in the rest of the series: