The urban myth that green building costs a big premium, does not have unique value and is difficult to finance is about to get “snoped” by Sun West Mortgage Company. They have engaged in a nationwide promotion of green building guidelines for multifamily. The effort seems to dwarf those of any other HUD-approved multifamily lender and may even set the stage for others to follow suit. Apartment owners and the building industry predictably insist that the greatest impediments to green building have been appraisers and lenders. Sun West Mortgage Company may be about to fix that.
Frankly, we were so excited about this program that we contacted Anson Snyder, Director of Multifamily Lending at Sun West Mortgage. For the first five minutes of our conversation, however, he interviewed me. Who was GreenLandlady? What was our readership? What was our target market? Actually, I felt like I was a little on the hot seat until he finally said warmly, “Okay, well, what did you want to know?” After we began to talk, I felt like I had bumped into an old friend at a USGBC Green Building Conference.
Editor: Before we get started on your green building campaign, what affect do you anticipate FHA’s recently revised guidelines for multifamily underwriting will have on credit underwriting?
Snyder: As the revised multifamily guidelines [released on July 6, 2010] reflect a lending philosophy that is focused on sustainability, we’ve reviewed the proposed changes at Sun West and believe they will be good for the industry on a long-term basis.
Editor: Certainly Sun West Mortgage has distinguished itself by actually promoting green building in the multifamily sector. Can you tell us how that happened?
Snyder: Much of the impetus in taking a leadership role in developing our green guidelines for multifamily housing was motivated by the value we see in more sustainable building and management practices.
Editor: Do your clients categorize as affordable housing [subsidized by the government] or market rate apartments?
Snyder: Our borrowers own and operate market rate and affordable rental housing throughout all areas of the United States.
Editor: Why did you select a campaign that presents sustainable building and management practices in an educational format?
Snyder: We wanted an approach that would get developers, property owners and managers engaged. We will also have webinars available to our customers so that they can walk through our green building guidelines. The webinars are interactive with our staff as well. It’s another way for us to connect with people in real time and an opportunity for us to listen to our customers.
Editor: In addition to new construction, the guidelines seem to have an even stronger focus on improving existing buildings. Was this your intent?
Snyder: Yes, it was. New green building is wonderful but there is all this great housing stock out there already. With interest rates as low as they are right now, why not take advantage of it? Apartment owners can refinance and improve their property and at the same time lock in a fantastic interest rate.
Editor: We’ve all heard the horror stories about the lack of available financing for apartment acquisitions, retrofits and refinances. What kind of mortgages is Sun West writing these days?
Snyder: All our products are 35 to 40 year HUD mortgages with fixed rates. The mortgages are non-recourse loans with a good loan-to-value ratio – not over-leveraged – and tailored to meet a principal’s capital needs.
Editor: Do you think there’s quantifiable value for the building owner who is considering a low-cost re-commissioning or a small retrofit?
Snyder: Yes, I do. Even focusing on minor retrofits in a building can improve the building’s life, lower operating costs and reduce on-going maintenance expenses. An owner can say, “Let’s change over to low-flow water fixtures”, and make a huge difference in water expense. We talk about the common areas, the building itself and the tenant spaces. For instance, there are all kinds of paints that are not toxic. Why not use them? For tenants there is added-value when that Mom and Pop owner can say, “This is a green building”.
Editor: When an owner is improving a property for sale or simply to improve performance, do Sun West’s guidelines indicate which features and improvements will have a substantial impact on value?
Snyder: Green elements can be measured in actual costs and lifetime savings. Our underwriters can review the work scope as it compares with the Property Capital Needs Assessment (PCNA), which is a required document for a loan refinance. Particularly when addressing deferred maintenance, green is a viable option for many borrowers and most buildings.
Editor: One of the barriers to incorporating high efficiency systems – like solar photovoltaic power generation in existing buildings – is always the high up-front cost. Is there any way a borrower can be assured that these costs will be included in the new mortgage amount from Sun West?
Snyder: As part of a loan refinance, some property owners are asking for cash-out that will be used towards upgrading a property’s systems, such as solar panels, waterless tanks, and low-e/dual pane windows. When speaking with your banker, let him or her know what is important to you and important to the building. You may be surprised at the advice your banker can offer towards a financing solution that includes those green features.
Editor: Managers often value features that require a low-cost or very minimal investment as this is an easier sell to their principals. Do your guidelines or educational program address anything for different levels of interest?
Snyder: Yes they do. We separate improvements into three levels of participation. The low cost improvements require minimal funds and generally have an immediate impact. This would be something like switching out incandescent lamps [lightbulbs] with CFLs. We demonstrate how although these new lamps seem expensive when compared to the inefficient ones, that is misleading. The lamps substantially lower utility expense, last ten times longer and therefore also require less maintenance. When the full life cycle analysis is performed by a property manager, the result speaks for itself. The medium cost improvements generally have a longer payback and the impact is more in the moderate category. The high cost improvements should be considered as long-term programs that might take ten or twenty years to reach a full payback. Of course, if grants, rebates, federal and state tax incentives and tax credits are taken into consideration, the payback period can often be cut in half.
Editor: As the first national lender who has attempted to codify green building standards into your portfolio, what do you hope to accomplish?
Snyder: Actually we wanted our clients thinking about going green for more than the sake of the buildings themselves. Of course, the building’s integrity matters to us as the property is the collateral for the mortgage, but we are committed to green building as a finite way to improve properties and extend building life. However, our company recognized that the most important aspect of green building improvements is the recognition that these properties are more than mere buildings. These are peoples’ homes. [Editor's note: This statement warmed my heart.]
Editor: What would define success for you with this campaign?
Snyder: The value of the educational impact we hope to achieve can be summed up pretty easily. It is all about the people who live and work in our multifamily communities. If we can help our clients understand that green building and management create a healthier resident life, we have achieved our objective.
Editor: Thank you, Anson, for enlightening us and thank you for your leadership in helping to green the multifamily community.
Anson Snyder is the Director of Multifamily Lending at Sun West Mortgage Company, Inc. located in Cerritos, California. He can be reached at 562-916-1457 or by email at anson.snyder@swmc.com. To receive a copy of Sun West’s Green Building Guidelines, please contact his office directly.
Other Articles of Interest:
FHA Mortgage Insurance Revisions for Multifamily
HUD, Money and Green Housing 2010
Will Clark: Carbon, Corporate Insight and Uncommon Sense